Two teams in the same company. The same ChatGPT or Claude licenses, the same budget, the same internal memo inviting everyone to “get into AI”. Six months later, one has reorganized its work around AI and saves several hours every week. The other opens the tool once a month, without really knowing what to do with it.
What separates them is their level of AI maturity. And that maturity plays out team by team.
To manage it, you need a common framework. Gartner’s AI maturity model offers one, in five levels, from simple awareness to transformation.
The 5 levels of AI maturity, from skepticism to transformation
Gartner’s AI maturity model describes five levels: Awareness, Active, Operational, Systemic and Transformational (Gartner, AI Maturity Model).
Levels 1 to 3: from awareness to deployment
At level 1 (“Awareness”), the team knows about AI but hasn’t taken the plunge. Few people use it, and only now and then. What you mostly hear: “AI? Just hype”, or “It’s too risky for what we do”.
At level 2 (“Active”), experimentation begins, but everyone on their own. People use ChatGPT or Claude to draft a message or look something up, but use stays individual and undocumented, and “I’m not really sure how to go about it” prevails.
At level 3 (“Operational”), the team has moved past experimentation. Use cases are deployed, dedicated AI agents (set up for one specific task) are shared and improved collectively, and the first metrics (KPIs) are tracked. It is a decisive milestone, because this is where AI becomes a collective reflex rather than an isolated practice.
Levels 4 and 5: scaling up and transformation
At level 4 (“Systemic”), the main work processes are redesigned around AI, a large part of the team uses it every day, and the return on investment (ROI) is measured and owned. Few companies have reached this stage so far: proof that it is demanding.
At level 5 (“Transformational”), the team achieves things that would simply have been impossible without AI. On its own, it delivers value that used to take entire teams, and it becomes a recognized reference within the company. This is the horizon, not the starting point.
A team is also made up of people with different relationships to AI. To help everyone progress at the right pace: the 5 employee profiles facing AI, and the method to get everyone on board.
How do you assess a team and move it up from one AI maturity level to the next?
Diagnose your teams’ AI maturity before acting
You can’t improve what you don’t measure. Before launching a training plan or buying a new tool, place each team. The right action isn’t the same for a level 1 team (raise awareness, show concrete cases) as for a level 3 team (even out skills, standardize processes).
Start from the front line to find AI use cases
A team doesn’t move up a level because management decided it should. It progresses when its members identify their own pain points, build the use cases that save them time, and share them with each other. This is Teamstarter’s conviction: the best AI use cases come from the people who do the work, not from a top-down plan. The company’s role is to create the framework (sharing rituals, prompt library, shared agents and so on) so that this momentum spreads.
Measure the ROI of AI to make the change stick
What separates level 3 from level 4 is measurement. As long as the gains remain a feeling (“I save two hours a week”), they remain fragile. By tracking simple metrics (time saved, quality, volume handled), you turn an intuition into proof, and proof into an argument that brings the skeptics on board.
Conclusion: making AI work in your teams
AI maturity can’t be decreed, and it can’t be boiled down to an adoption percentage. It is built team by team, level by level, from the first individual reflex to the uses that redefine the job.
The good news? You don’t need to transform everything at once. You just need to know where each team stands, and help it take the next step.
Start by looking, team by team, at where you really stand.
FAQ: your questions about AI maturity
What are the AI maturity levels?
Gartner’s AI maturity model describes five levels. Awareness: the team knows about AI but uses it little. Active: everyone experiments on their own. Operational: use cases and agents are shared, and metrics are tracked. Systemic: the main processes are redesigned around AI and the ROI is measured. Transformational: the team achieves what would have been impossible without AI.
How do you assess your teams’ AI maturity?
Place each team before acting, because maturity plays out team by team: two teams with the same licenses can be at very different levels. The right action plan isn’t the same for a level 1 team, which needs awareness built through concrete cases, as for a level 3 team, which needs to even out its skills and standardize its processes.
How do you move a team up in AI maturity?
A team progresses when its members identify their own pain points, build the use cases that save them time and share them with each other. The company creates the framework: sharing rituals, a prompt library, shared agents. To move from level 3 to level 4, you need to measure the gains (time saved, quality, volume handled) instead of relying on a feeling.
Sources
Gartner — AI Maturity Model (5-level framework: Awareness, Active, Operational, Systemic, Transformational) — https://www.gartner.com/en/chief-information-officer/research/ai-maturity-model-toolkit
